I really found this article helpful. My opinion of "Peer Assessment" is I think it is something to consider but I was surprised to read that students will really evaluate themselves after they complete an assignment. As for grading their peer's, thats another story. I think this would be something I would have my students do during a writer's workshop but not on a weekly basis.
The "One in Four Rule" is a new one to me. This is actually something I would consider. I would probably tie this in with the "stamping method". For instance the 3 that I am not grading I would use the "stamping method" for. The only thing I disagree about the stamping method is when I was in elementary/middle school and my teacher would hand back my paper I would always be annoyed with just a "check" or "stamp". I would always think to myself, "okay what a waste. Am I even getting credit?" or I would think the teacher didn't even read it. I always was excited it there were actual words or comments written on my paper. These are things I will be keeping in mind when I grade my students papers.
Which is why I really like the idea for the "Student Journals" but tweaked a little. I would ideally like to collect them every other week, on a Friday. Something I would do different is have the students leave a blank page for me to not just stamp or grade the selected assignments but allow me to write my comments to the student. Thats why I think collecting them every other week would be a timely fashion. If I spend about 10min on each students journal and I have an average of 25 students thats about four hours I would have to spend on grading every two weeks. This could ideally be done over and weekend and then students would receive their feedback on Monday on the page inside their journal.
The "One in Four Rule" is a new one to me. This is actually something I would consider. I would probably tie this in with the "stamping method". For instance the 3 that I am not grading I would use the "stamping method" for. The only thing I disagree about the stamping method is when I was in elementary/middle school and my teacher would hand back my paper I would always be annoyed with just a "check" or "stamp". I would always think to myself, "okay what a waste. Am I even getting credit?" or I would think the teacher didn't even read it. I always was excited it there were actual words or comments written on my paper. These are things I will be keeping in mind when I grade my students papers.
Which is why I really like the idea for the "Student Journals" but tweaked a little. I would ideally like to collect them every other week, on a Friday. Something I would do different is have the students leave a blank page for me to not just stamp or grade the selected assignments but allow me to write my comments to the student. Thats why I think collecting them every other week would be a timely fashion. If I spend about 10min on each students journal and I have an average of 25 students thats about four hours I would have to spend on grading every two weeks. This could ideally be done over and weekend and then students would receive their feedback on Monday on the page inside their journal.


